Trustees, Brokers, and Advisors Who Are Hired to Manage Trusts And Other Fiduciary Investment Accounts Must Act Like “A Prudent Investor”
These cases are governed by the “Prudent Investor Rule” because trustees and brokers or advisors who are given discretion and paid to monitor and manage trusts or investment accounts are “fiduciaries.” In some cases, the trustee is a financial professional who makes the investment decisions personally. In others, he or she is essentially an administrator who hires a qualified professional to manage the accounts. In the latter case, the broker or advisor hired becomes the “fiduciary,” the one held to the “Prudent Investor Rule” standard. In short, the Rule states that trustees or other fiduciaries must manage the accounts in a way that “a prudent investor” would manage his or her own money.
The “Prudent Investor Rule” is the modern version and derived from the “Prudent Man Rule” established in the early 1800s in a case brought by Harvard College against a trustee it alleged to have mismanaged a trust. Judge Putnam was the first to formulate the rule governing management of trusts:
Do what you will, the capital is at hazard. All that can be required of a trustee to invest is that he shall conduct himself faithfully and exercise a sound discretion. He is to observe how men of prudence, discretion, and intelligence manage their own affairs, considering the probable income, as well as the probable safety of the capital to be invested … .
This standard has not changed much in substance over two centuries and been codified in statutes, such as the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) and Florida Statute 518.11 titled “Investments by Fiduciaries: Prudent Investor Rule.”
The modern statutory “Prudent Investor Rule” standard generally requires consideration of all of the “purposes, terms, distribution requirements, and other circumstances” of the trust or retirement plan. It requires the “fiduciary” to exercise “reasonable care and caution” in managing the “investment portfolio as a whole” and as part of “an overall investment strategy” that incorporates “risk and return objectives reasonably suitable to the trust, guardianship or probate estate” investment portfolio. And if the “fiduciary” has special skills, like a professional broker or advisor, he/she is “under a duty to use those special skills” and will be judged accordingly. The “Prudent Investor Rule” is a test of conduct at the time the investment decision is being made, not performance. The “fiduciary” has a general duty to diversify investments unless it is “reasonably” believed not to be in the “best interests” of the beneficiaries to do so. Ultimately, and consistent with the earliest “Prudent Man” standard, the “fiduciary” has the duty to follow a strategy that considers both the “reasonable production of income and safety of capital.”
LOOKING TO LEARN MORE: Click here for related articles about Mismanagement of Trust.
Hear From Our Clients
At The Law Offices of Robert Wayne Pearce, P.A., we believe the ultimate barometer of our success is surpassing the expectation of our clients.
The following clients have direct knowledge of our firm's processes from the inside and experienced our fierce advocacy.
Hear From Our Clients
"Bob Pearce is the real-life Marvel Hero who fights for small investors against brokerage institutions who manage investors’ hard-earned money carelessly, and even worse, conduct fraud outright."
Bob Pearce is the real-life Marvel Hero who fights for small investors against brokerage institutions who manage investors’ hard-earned money carelessly, and even worse, conduct fraud outright. For years, we were misled by a brokerage firm who told us they would correct the wrong or compensate us for their mistakes. Only after we started working with Bob, we realized how powerful and wonderful it is to have a top legal expert by your side. Bob is immensely detail oriented, knowledgeable, professional, and confident. We are more than happy with the outcome Bob achieved for us within just a few months. Thank you, Bob!- Q Wang -
“Robert Pearce is part of that unusual breed of lawyers that are able to create empathy with clients and thoroughly adopt their cause”
No half efforts here. He and his group of professionals are outstanding strategists that can execute with precise fervor and unyielding determination. Theirs is a huge wave of facts, research, precedents and preparation, that has impressed me in its thoroughness and creativity, and most importantly with the results. No stone goes unturned and no effort is ever spared. In my book, he and they are those of a very rare kind that one wants to keep for a very long time.- Ramon Flores-Esteves -
“Just like the song from HAMILTON, it's so nice to have Bob Pearce on your side.”
Just like the song from HAMILTON, it's so nice to have Bob Pearce on your side. He is the consumate plaintiff's lawyer: smart. dedicated, fully able to try a case but a great negotiator in a mediation. He did a wonderful job for us, fully supporting us through the process and more than holding his own against a large national law firm.- Maurice Z. -
"Mr. Pearce and his staff exceeded all of our expectations."
Mr. Pearce and his staff exceeded all of our expectations. We were able to reach a settlement that was of our complete satisfaction, all within a very smooth, professional and efficient process. Mr. Pearce is now not only our lawyer but our family friend. We highly recommend him and his team!- Severiano L. -
"For the best fighting chance, Robert Pearce is the lawyer you want in your corner."
This law firm is the real deal. We were so lucky that they took our case as they have so much experience in securities and all the wrongdoing that happens in these investment companies where they mislead you and your money (as in our case) into schemes that are not what you think they are. Mr. Robert Pearce is one of the best lawyers around, a truly professional who will fight for you and will tell you as it is all the time. We could not have gone thru this experience if it was not for all the advice, guidance and support he and all of his staff and associates brought to the game. For the best fighting chance, Robert Pearce is the lawyer you want in your corner.- Astrid M. -
"He never felt intimidated and his study of the case and perseverance prevailed at all times."
Attorney Robert Pearce was our lawyer in a case against a Brokerage Firm and I'm witness to his ability and intelligence to deal with lawyers from the most prominent law firm in New York which was the key to recovering much of our losses cheered by their negligence. He never felt intimidated and his study of the case and perseverance prevailed at all times.- Jose A. C. -
"In the end, Bob and I had the last laugh when the arbitrators awarded me almost 6 million dollars."
No lawyer except Bob said I had a chance of winning. When UBS Lawyers laughingly offered me zero to settle the dispute, Bob became even more determined to prove everybody wrong. Bob was extremely prepared, and always a step ahead of the opposing attorneys throughout the arbitration. In the end, Bob and I had the last laugh when the arbitrators awarded me almost 6 million dollars.- J. Blanco -
"Every meeting and phone call was made with dedication and desire to help our family every step of the way."
Robert's team is excellent. They are very competitive in what they do and they are very responsible. Every meeting and phone call was made with dedication and desire to help our family every step of the way. Their professionalism, responsibility and empathy assured us that we were in good hands. Recommend to everyone.- Mayra A. -