More and more disputes are being resolved in alternative dispute resolution (ADR) forums these days. The primary ADR methods are arbitration and mediation. Whether you are an investor or a broker, the odds are that you have agreed in an account opening agreement or self-regulatory organization membership agreement to resolve any dispute with any stock or commodities brokerage firm in an arbitration forum outside the courtroom such as the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), National Futures Association (NFA), American Arbitration Association (AAA) or the Judicial Arbitration and Mediation Services (JAMS) organizations at locations throughout the United States.
Arbitration is generally a more expeditious and economical dispute resolution process than courtroom litigation, which can go on for years and be very expensive to comply with court rules and pretrial discovery procedures such as depositions, interrogatories and examinations, which do not generally take place in arbitration. Arbitrations are generally not open to the public and the documents and testimony presented are held in a confidential manner by the forum and the parties pursuant to the rules of the arbitration forum and the parties agreement to arbitrate their dispute. The only document that is generally made public is the Award itself, which the parties may take and file in court if necessary to enforce the Award by confirming it to a Final Judgment.
The Law Offices of Robert Wayne Pearce Represents Clients in Arbitration Throughout Florida and Nationwide
The arbitrations handled by the attorneys at The Law Offices of Robert Wayne Pearce, P.A., generally involve securities broker-dealers who are members or individuals who are associate members of FINRA and so this explanation of arbitration will focus on FINRA arbitration proceedings. Attorney Pearce has arbitrated and mediated numerous FINRA disputes involving complex legal issues in his practice areas. To learn more about our arbitration and alternative dispute resolution services, contact us today to schedule a confidential consultation.The Arbitrators
In most arbitrations, lawyers, accountants and other business persons decide disputes between two or more parties in a business setting instead of having a judge or jury decide your dispute in a courtroom. The individuals who decide these disputes are generally experienced in the particular industry in which the dispute has arisen. These individuals are generally selected by the parties and compose an arbitration panel that is charged with the responsibility of making a fair and final decision related to the dispute. These arbitrators will review the parties' papers or pleadings outlining the claims and defenses related to the dispute, conduct a hearing where the parties present documents as evidence and witnesses who give testimony as evidence in a manner less formal than a courtroom. The arbitrators then listen to the factual and legal arguments of the parties and make a decision to fully resolve the dispute.
FINRA and NFA provide the primary dispute resolution services for their members and their customers who invest in the securities and commodities markets. The majority of arbitration claims involving the securities industry are filed with FINRA. Commodities industry disputes are generally processed in a similar manner and under the rules of the NFA.The FINRA Arbitration Process
If you are an investor or a stockbroker, the FINRA arbitration process began when you opened your account at or became associated with a stock brokerage firm and signed an account opening agreement or employment agreement, respectfully. Virtually all agreements with all brokerage firms contain an agreement to arbitrate all controversies and disputes you may have with the brokerage firm. In those agreements, you agree to abide by the rules of FINRA, particularly the FINRA Code of Arbitration Procedure (the FINRA Code") and waive a right to have your dispute resolved in a court of law before a judge or jury. The FINRA Code sets forth all of the procedures and rules governing the arbitration. It describes the controversies that are eligible for arbitration and those that are not subject to the arbitration agreement. There are general arbitration rules governing the parties' conduct in arbitration. The FINRA Code prescribes the minimum content and when to file a claim, counterclaim, cross-claim and third party claim and answer to any and all those types of claims. There are rules governing the appointment, disqualification and authority of arbitrators along with prehearing procedures and discovery rules. There are rules governing the conduct of the hearing, the type of evidence that may be presented and the manner in which the hearing is concluded. The FINRA Code sets forth the fee schedule and the manner in which the Award is issued by the arbitrators to the parties.Filing a Claim
The formal arbitration process begins with the filing of a statement of claim by you or your attorneys. The investor who files the claim is referred to as the "Claimant" in the arbitration proceeding. If you are an investor, the statement of claim is the most important document in your case. This document describes what happened and why you or your attorney believe you are entitled to win a monetary award or other relief against the brokerage firm. This is the document that will provide the arbitrators with their first and most important impressions of you and your case against the brokerage firm. It is important that you and/or your lawyers write a clear, concise, accurate and honest account of what happened and a compelling argument for why you should win the arbitration.
FINRA charges you for its services. There are a nonrefundable filing fees to initiate the arbitration depending on the size of your monetary claim ranging from $50 to $1,800 for investors and stockbrokers who initiate claims against brokerage firms. The fees for disputes initiated by member brokerage firms are greater and range from $225 to $3,700 and those member firms can be surcharged for additional amounts when they become parties to arbitration proceedings.
The arbitration claims can be filed in writing and mailed to the main FINRA office in New York City or filed electronically. FINRA is in the process of going totally paperless for their convenience as well as for the convenience of the parties and arbitrators.
The brokerage firm is referred to as the "Respondent" in the arbitration proceeding. Once filed, the claim is served by FINRA on the brokerage firm with instructions to the Respondent to file an answer within 45 business days. If you are responding to an arbitration claim, it is equally important to file a clear, concise, accurate and honest account of what happened along with a compelling legal argument as to why the claims made against you have no basis in law or fact and justify a dismissal in the final Award.The Arbitration Hearing
The type of arbitration hearing conducted can vary depending on the size of the arbitration claim. If your claim is for a monetary award less than $100,000, it is a "small claim" that is usually decided by a single public arbitrator. If the claim is under $50,000, the arbitrator will generally render a decision based solely upon the content of the written statements and the supporting documents submitted by each party without any testimony. If the claim is between $50,000 and $100,000 the single arbitrator will conduct a hearing where you and your witnesses appear and give testimony and introduce documents into evidence for that single arbitrator's consideration and decision. If the claim exceeds $100,000, three arbitrators will be appointed to hear the testimony and resolve your claim based upon all of the evidence. An Award is entered based upon a majority vote by the arbitrators in your case.
The final arbitration hearing takes place in either one of FINRA's regional offices or one or more hearing sites selected by FINRA in the state where you reside. Depending on where you reside and the number of claims filed, the time it takes from the filing of a claim to the conduct of a final hearing where your dispute is heard and resolved is 12 to 16 months. Most arbitration proceedings involving larger claims and 3 or more arbitrators take 3 to 5 consecutive days, but it is not unheard of for some very complex and large claims to take weeks to be heard. There are generally two 4-hour hearing sessions during each hearing day. At the end of the presentation of evidence, the arbitrators will decide the case privately in additional hearing sessions.
In three-person Arbitration Panels, a qualified Chairperson will be appointed as a spokesperson for the entire arbitration panel and be the arbitrator directing the conduct of the hearing. The Chairperson will begin the arbitration hearing by reading formal notices to the parties and requiring each arbitrator and person present, who will testify as a witness, to be sworn in under oath as an arbitrator or witness. Each party with a lawyer will then make a brief opening statement of what they intend to prove at the hearing. The Claimant or his/her lawyer then begins to present the evidence through witnesses giving live testimony and documents to prove the claims. Some witnesses may appear by video conference or telephone if they are not within the locale and are permitted to do so by the arbitrators. After the Claimant and his/her witnesses testify, the Respondent or his/her lawyers may question the witnesses. The arbitrators can ask questions of the witnesses at any time during the testimony but usually wait until the parties or their attorneys finish their examination of the parties and non-party witnesses. After the Claimant presents all of the evidence in support of his/her claims, the Respondent presents his/her defense in the same manner. At the conclusion of the Respondent's case, the parties or their attorneys may present closing statements, which are summations of the testimony and documents introduced into evidence and arguments as to why their side should win the case.Decision and Award
The Arbitration Panel's decision is called an "Award," which is final and binding on the parties unless it is successfully challenged in court on limited grounds within a statutory time period. The Award is made after all the parties complete the presentation of the evidence and the arbitrators close the record and deliberate privately to reach a decision of the majority of the members of the Arbitration Panel. The arbitrators, with the assistance of the FINRA administrative staff, will prepare the Award generally within 30 days of the close of the record. The Award will identify the parties, generally describe the claims and defenses and state who prevailed on each claim and the amount to be awarded, if anything, to the Claimant or Counterclaimant in the dispute or order a dismissal of all claims, meaning the Respondent prevailed. The arbitrators will then assess the fees and expenses of the arbitration proceeding against one or more parties. Generally, the arbitration hearing session fees and expenses are ordered to be split 50-50 by the parties. The Award is then mailed to the parties or their attorneys. If the brokerage firm loses the arbitration, it is given 30 days to make payment, and if it fails to do so, the Claimant may petition FINRA to suspend the brokerage firm or broker's license and petition the courts to confirm the arbitration award to a Final Judgment in order to collect the amount due through attachment, levy and garnishment proceedings.Free Initial Consultation With Attorneys Who Can Handle Your FINRA, NFA, AAA and JAMS Arbitration Problems
The Law Offices of Robert Wayne Pearce, P.A. understands the arbitration process and knows what is at stake in securities, commodities and investment law matters and constantly strives to secure the most favorable possible result. Mr. Pearce provides a complete review of your case and fully explains your legal options. The firm works to ensure that you have all of the information necessary to make a sound decision before any action is taken in your case.
For dedicated representation by a law firm with substantial experience in all kinds of securities, commodities and investment disputes, contact the firm by phone at 561-338-0037, toll free at 800-732-2889 or via e-mail. We can also arrange a meeting with you at offices located in Boca Raton, Fort Lauderdale, Miami and West Palm Beach, Florida and elsewhere if we believe you have a viable case or defense.